Children's Lit Book Reviews
Friday, February 12, 2010
Curious George and the Firefighters
Summary: Curious George is a curious little monkey. He goes to a fire station and, being curious, he starts to try on or see everything in that he can reach. This creates some problems when the fire alarm rings and the firemen can't find their boots and coats because George has mixed them up. Finally, they go to the fire and George jumps on the truck with them. When he gets to the fire, he gets in the way, again curious. He is told to sit on the bench. He does for a minute then starts playing with the children who are watching the fire. He fins some balls in a bucket and starts juggling for the children, and they are not afraid of the fire any more. At the end, George is praised for helping keep the children calm, and they are all rewarded with a ride on the firetruck.
Who would benefit from reading this book?: It is a good book for children who are not paying attention and maybe a little bit too curious. But it will not discourage them from investigating. It is definitely for the beginning reader who can follow a relatively simple plot.
What problems/conflicts can this book potentially cause?: As with most beginning reader books, there is little conflict that I can see. Some parents might be concerned that George doesn't follow directions well and still doesn't get in trouble for failure to do so.
My Reaction: I feel that George is portrayed as being curious but also as good. The illustrations follow the story well and support the actions. The book shows the importance of paying attention to direction, trying new things, being brave, staying out of the way when dangerous things are going on, and that one is rewarded for doing good things.
Corduroy
Summary: A little bear in corduroy overalls is on the shelf in a store. His name is Corduroy. He has one button missing from his overall strap, so he is passed by each time children come to get toys. One day, a little girl comes up and looks him right in the eyes and tells her mother that this is just the bear she wants. However, the mother, seeing the missing button, decides that is not the bear for her daughter. The little bear is very disappointed, but now he knows he is missing a button. When the store closes, he decides to look for his button. He starts through the store. He comes to a place where the floor moves under him. It is an escalator that takes him to the next floor, the furniture department. He sees all the furniture a decides he is now in a castle. He sees a bed, and gets on it. He finds a button on the mattress, but when he tries to pick up the button, it will not come loose because it's a button on the mattress cover. He loses his grip on the button, falls of the bed, hits a lamp, and it crashes down. A night watchman, hearing the crash, comes to investigate. He sees the lamp knocked over and looks for who might be hidden that caused the crash. He sees two fuzzy ears sticking out from under the cover on the bed and takes Corduroy back to his shelf. Next morning, the same little girl shows up and has money she has saved that her mother allows her to spend for the bear. She takes him home and her room is not a castle, but small. It is, in fact, just right for him. She also sews on a button so that his overalls will stay up.
Who would benefit from reading this book? Again, it is intended for beginning readers. The illustrations are just right for the book, and the teddy bear is adorable. I think it will be enjoyed by any young reader who reads it.
What problems/conflicts can this book potentially cause: I seen not at all. It is even very politically correct as the little girl is African American and the night watchman is caucasian. There is no violence and the little bear's unhappiness is turned to joy.
By: Margaret Wang
Illustrated by: Christine Schneider
Designed by: Treesh Runnels
Publisher: Piggy Toes Press
Copyright: 2002
Summary: The story begins with a cookie missing and the book's purpose is to allow the reader to solve the mystery of who is stealing the cookies. The kitty, bunny, bird, duck, fish, guinea pig, frog and mouse are all investigated in the course of finding the person who stole the cookies. Finally, the mother and the children find Dad with the final cookie in his hand. He admits, "I ate the cookies. Now all I can do is share." It is a beautifully illustrated little book and the expressions on the faces of the characters being investigated are delightful.
Who would benefit from reading this book?: It is one that is definitely written for the small child who is just beginning to process questions and figure out simple solutions.
What Problems/conflicts can the book potentially cause?: It is such a simple story that it probably will not cause any conflicts or concerns.
My reaction: The Father quickly admits to having eaten the cookies, so there is probably no intent of stealing the cookies. Then his willingness to share the last cookie is about all one could expect of him.
Publisher: Greenwillow Books
Copyright: 2004
Pages: 40
Reading Level: 4-8
Genre: Picture Book
Award: Caldecott Award
"Henkes creates another winner in this simple, charming story about a naive little kitten who mistakes a round, shining moon for a bowl of milk."
- Booklist
Who would benefit from reading this book?: I think that the readability of this book is quite simple, and that even beginner readers could read this and understand it. The story is short but really cute for little children. It would be a great book to share as a read aloud, bedtime story for younger children.
What problems/conflicts could this book potentially cause?: I don't think that there are any problems or conflicts that this book would cause. It is a book meant for younger aged children but is so well put together that anyone could enjoy it.
My reaction: This is a really cute book. It is simple and there''s not much to it. As an education major it made me ponder the stages of learning. This little kitten had to learn for herself that the moon wasn't really a bowl of milk in the sky. While coming to the knowledge herself, she learned valuable lessons while on her little trek. I enjoyed this book and recommend it to young readers as it can teach them about the same steps of learning as the kitten experienced.
By: Peggy Rathmann
Publisher: Putnam Juvenile; Unknown edition
Copyright: 1995
Pages: 40
Reading Level: 4-8
Genre: Picture Book
Award: Caldecott Award
"A fresh, funny story about the wonders of teamwork."
-School Library Journal
Who would benefit from reading this book?: I think all young children would benefit from this good book. It teaches the importance of teamwork, and it is a fairly easy read.
What problems/concerns could this book potentially cause?: I don't think this book would cause any problems.
My reaction: This is a great book, and I enjoyed reading it. I recommend it for all beginning readers.
By: Hans Christian Anderson
Age: 8-12
Who would benefit from reading this fairy tale?: I think that everyone who would take the time to read this fairy tale will walk away satisfied. There are many great morals and values that are taught within this book. I liked especially how it showed the love a mother had for her child.
What problems/conflicts could this fairy tale potentially cause?: This fairy tale is quite violent. The loving mother must do several things in order to find her child.
My reaction: I loved this fairy tale. This really shows what a loving mother would do for her child. This mother in this fairy tale went as far as crying her eyes out so that she could have her child returned. But once her vision was restored and she saw the future of her child, out of love she let her child go. That's such a strong storyline, and it makes me think about the love that my mom has for me. I would recommend this to a very mature audience.
By: Charles Perrault
Ages:8-12
Summary: There was once a fierce man named Bluebeard. He had been married many times, but no one knew what had happen to his many wives. Therefore, he was avoided by many of the local girls. When Bluebeard visited one of his neighbors and asked to marry one of her two daughters, the girls were terrified, and each tried to pass him on to the other. Somehow, he was able to persuade the younger daughter to marry him and, after the wedding, she went to live with him.Very shortly thereafter, Bluebeard announced that he had to leave the country for a while, and he gave over all the keys of the chateau to his new wife, including the key to one small room that he forbade her to enter. He then left the county, leaving the house in her hands. Immediately, she was overcome with the desire to see what was in the forbidden room, decided to satisfy her curiosity by taking a peek into the room.The wife immediately discovered the room's secret. There were the dead bodies of her husband's former wives hung from hooks on the walls. She then locked the door, but blood had somehow gotten onto the key and it would not wash off. Bluebeard returned and had figured out what his wife had done. In a rage he threatened to kill her immediately, but she begged him to give her fifteen minutes so she could say her last prayer. He agreed, and she ran up into the highest tower with her sister, Anne, and they locked themselves in. While Bluebeard, sword in hand, tried to break down the door, the sisters waited for their two brothers to arrive. At the last moment, as Bluebeard was about to deliver the fatal blow, the brothers broke into the castle. As Bluebird attempted to flee, they killed him. He left no heirs except his wife, and she inherited all his great fortune.
Who would benefit from reading this fairy tale?: This is such a great fairy tale, and I think the story teaches good morals and values. The moral of the story, to me, is that you should always obey what you are asked to do because when you don't there is always a consequence for your misbehavior. At first blush, one might think the moral of the story is that she should not have disobeyed her husband. But it is deeper than that. In this case, the young wife finds out what Bluebeard had done that he should not have done, and she is able to overcome his evil designs. he suffers the consequences of his actions. In this way, the story also teaches that there is good and evil and that good can overcome evil.
What problems/conflicts could this fairy tale potentially cause?: One main problem with this fairy tale is death. That might stop a lot of parents from sharing this story with their children because some might think it is violent.
My reaction: I enjoyed reading this fairy tale. I did find this quite violent, but I do think the moral of the story is a good one. Therefore, I recommend this book to a mature children readers.
Thursday, February 11, 2010
By: Joesph Jacobs
Ages:8-12
Who would benefit from reading this fairy tale?: I think everyone that would read this fairy tale would benefit from it. It has simple themes about bragging and consequences that follow when people lie about being greater then they are. In this case the girl was placed at hazard because of the mother's lies.
What problems/conflicts could this fairy tale potentially cause?: The one problem that seems to reoccur through all of the fairy tales during this era is death. This might be scary for young readers who don't understand that it is just a fairy tale. Therefore, certain parents might be hesitant to read this fairy tale to their children because the life of the girl is threatened many times.
My reaction: I like this fairy tale and found it quite entertaining. I liked how it followed the Grimm Brother's fairy tale very closely. It was funny to see differences in both, though. I thought it was good, and I would recommend it to those who are more mature, even though young in years.
Sweetheart Roland-#56
By: The Brothers Grimm
Ages: 8-12
Eventually, the stepdaughter would have to return to steal the wand of the witch. The girl took the wand and turned herself into a duck and her lover into a pond in order to flee from the witch. Later, to disguise herself from the witch, she once again turned herself into a rose in a hedge and her lover into a fiddle player. Once the witch came, she recognized them and asked to pick the rose. As the witch bent down to pick the rose Roland played his fiddle causing the witch to dance in a thorny hedge until she died. Immediately, Roland returned home to his father to arrange the wedding with the stepdaughter, leaving behind stepdaughter behind until the plans were made. Roland ran into another girl who caused him to forget about the stepdaughter, and he makes plans to wed the new girl. Eventually the stepdaughter was picked by a local shepherd and was revealed but promised to be the keeper of the shepherd. At the wedding it was tradition that the girls must sing for the groomsmen. Others refused to sing, but the stepdaughter, who was one of the girls. didn't refuse. Her song reached the ears of Roland. He married the stepdaughter, and they lived happily ever after.
Who would benefit from reading this fairy tale?: This fairy tale is a classic and will always remain a Grimm Brothers favorite. I think that this is a part of literature history and should be read to all. Everyone would benefit from reading it.
What problems/conflicts would this fairy tale potentially cause?: There are several problems with this fairy tale and there are probably good reasons to why some parents and even teachers would be hesitant to share it with their children. One would be the way that the characters die. With younger readers, it could potentially scare them because of the death of both the daughter and the witch.
My reaction: This was my first time reading this fairy tale and, at first, I was apprehensive about it because of the death of the daughter in the beginning. But I ended up really liking the fairy tale and would share it with older readers who would enjoy a piece of old fairy tale literature.
The Orphan Boy
Publisher: Sandpiper
Copyright: 1990
Pages: 32
Reading Level: 4-8
Genre: Picture Book/Folk tale
Award: N/A
"Outstanding."
- Kirkus Review
Who would benefit from reading this book?: This is a great book and it teaches many great lessons such as responsibility, trust and character. The readability of the book is fairly easy for children from around grade three andabove to read and comprehend. This book is helpful when wanting to educate children about folk tales and legends from other countries.
What problems/conflicts could this book potentially cause? There are no problems or conflicts that would prevent anyone from wanting to read this book. It is a book that was written to inspire people.
My reaction: I think this book was well put together. The illustrations, which are done by Paul Morin, keep up with the text and are absolutely beautiful. I would share this book with anyone and recommend that all who are interested in learning African culture go to this book as a source of knowledge.
Mrs. Chicken and the Hungry Crocodile
Publisher: Henry Holt and Co.
Copyright: 2003
Pages: 32
Reading Level: 4-8
Genre: Picture Book/Fantasy
Award: Charlotte Zolotow Award-Honor Book
"Readers young and old will cluck with delight"
-Publishers Weekly
Who would benefit from reading this book?: This is a great book for children of all ages to read. I think there is a moral hidden deep within this story and teaches children to be happy with what they have and not to venture too far out looking for bigger and better.
What problems/conflicts could this book potentially cause?: I don't think that this book contains any problems that would make it controversial.
My reaction: This book is funny!!! Once again I found myself laughing out loud. I think the authors did a good job in teaching important life lessons. I liked how they transformed this Liberian folk tale into a beautiful book with wonderful illustrations to match the background of the tale.
The Man Who Walked Between The Towers
Publisher: Square Fish
Copyright: 2003
Pages: 40
Reading Level: 4-8
Genre: Picture Book/Ficition
Award: Caldecott Award
"Gerstein's dramatic paintings include some perspectives bound to take any reader's breath away. Truly affecting is the book's final painting of the imagined imprint of the towers, now existing "in memory"-linked by Philippe and his high wire."
- Publishers Weekly
Who would benefit from reading this book? I think that because this book is based off a true story and holds some historical significance that everyone would benefit from reading it. The story is especially special to those citizens of New York City who might have witnessed this miraculous event. Now, since the towers are no longer standing following 9/11, it means even more to them. It is an easy read and children would be entertained from it.
What problems/concerns could this book potentially cause?: I don't think that there is any problems or concerns contained within this book. However, there might be concern because the performer knew that he was breaking the law and refused to obey the orders of the policemen.
My reaction: I wish I could have been there to see this wonderful event unfold. However, after having read this book, it made me feel like I was somewhat there stand amongst the crowd. I loved this book for the detail in text but also for the gorgeous illustrations also done by Mordical Gerstein. As a future teacher I will be placing this book in my classroom in upcoming years.
Probuditi
By: Chris Van Allsburg
Publisher: Houghton Mifflin Books for Children
Copyright: 2006
Pages: 32
Reading Level: 4-8
Genre: Picture Book/Fantasy
Award: N/A
"Chris Van Allsburg, a master of surprise endings, wraps a captivating story in lush, warm full-page illustrations in pencil over pastels in burnt sienna that ooze the heat of a summer day in the early 1940s."
-Chicago Sun-Times
The boys return home, greatly impressed by the magician's performance, and Calvin then finds himself having to watch over Trudy while his mother goes to the beauty parlor. The boys run upstairs and create a contraption made out of Erector parts and somehow talk Trudy into being a part of there experiment. She agrees and they sit her down in front of homemade machine. Within seconds she becomes glassy-eyed and completely unaware of her surroundings. Calvin then leans over and tells Trudy to begin acting like a dog. Trudy jumps off the chair and then begins panting and rolling around like a dog. The rest of the afternoon they play around with Trudy in her hypnotized state of mind. They finally decide to turn her back but come to the realization that all of their tactics are not working. In a last minute effort, they load Trudy up in a wagon and trek across town to visit Mr. Lomax. After attempting to visit Mr. Lomax, the boys return home only to see Calvin's mom pulling up the driveway. Rodney runs away and Calvin is left standing there with his sister, Trudy, crying her eyes out. Calvin is then sent to his room and his sister brings him a peanut butter sandwich, a pickle, and a glass of milk. Calvin makes fun of Trudy for acting like a dog in her hypnotized state. Trudy then tells Calvin she didn't remember anything about the afternoon but did enjoy the ice cream that was given to her earlier in their trek to see Mr. Lomax.
Who would benefit from reading this book?: Anyone who reads this book will walk away happy and gratified. The readability of the book is easy. It would make a great book to be read to children of all ages. Intermediate readers might find it enjoyable to read by themselves, but it is just an all around great book to read aloud in classrooms and in bedtime story situations.
What problems/concerns could this book potentially cause?: In my opinion I don't think that there is any problems or concerns with this book. However, some might disagree, because of two different scenarios in the book. The first might be that the mother allowed the children to go to a magic show by themselves without any adult supervision. The second might be related to some sort of racial connotation because of their African American ethnicity. There is an instance within the book where Allsburg has the little African American girl on all fours, drinking water out of a bowl like an animal.
My reaction: I was reading this book in the library, and there were certain parts where I found myself laughing out loud with people giving me funny looks. This is a great book, and I personally find it very funny and enjoyable. I think that Allsburg did a great job with this book. His illustrations, as always, are absolutely stunning. I would recommend this to all who are looking for a funny and entertaining book to read aloud to children of all ages.
Goggles
By: Ezra Jack Keats
Publisher: Puffin
Copyright: 1969
Pages: 40
Reading Level: 4-8
Genre: Picture Book
Award: Caldecott Honor Book
"Everyone wants the goggles Peter found in this fast-paced Caldecott Honor winner."
-Publishers Weekly
Who would benefit from reading this book?: This is a great story. It's an easy read making it enjoyable for readers of all ages.
What problems/conflicts could this book potentially cause?: While it is a good book to read there is one problem that I see this book could cause. There is an instance where Peter goes to fight the "big boys." Some might say that this book supports fighting and would discourage other from reading it because of that. But, to me, the book supports defending one's property when others are seeking to damage it or take it away.
My reaction: I liked the book and enjoyed reading it. The illustrations are unique in that the "big boys" seem to be dark shadows while the author illustrates the two main characters quite well. Last summer I spent some time in New York City, and I wonder if Keats was describing what it might have been like for younger boys growing up during that period of time in what was known as America's toughest ghetto.
By: Cynthia Rylant
Publisher: Puffin
Copyright: 1982
Pages: 32
Reading Level: 4-8
Genre: Picture Book
Award: Caldecott Honor Book
"An evocative remembrance of the simple pleasures in country living; splashing in the swimming hole, taking baths in the kitchen, sharing family times, each is eloquently portrayed here in both the misty-hued scenes and in the poetic text."
- Association for Childhood Education International
Who would benefit from reading this book?: This book is great for readers of all ages. It's a taste of what its like for a little girl either growing up with her grandparents or visiting her grandparents in the mountains. The readability of this book is quite simply what makes it a desirable book for many to enjoy.
What problems/conflicts could this book potentially cause?: I don't think that this book would cause many problems if any at all, although there are some religious aspects such as baptism that might make this a controversial book to read in public schools. But I think it well depicts the life of a little girl spending time with her grandparents.
My reaction: Wow! This book hits close to home for me. I've done many things and been to many places similar to what is depicted within this book. Both of my parents were born and raised in West Virgina, and we would travel back to West Virgina in the summer time during school breaks. My Dad would walk my sister and me through the hollers of West Virgina ,reminiscing of these exact, same events talked about within the book. Amazingly enough, I can easily relate to this book. I'm glad I found this book in the library.
By: Julius Lester
Publisher: Puffin
Copyright: 2008
Pages: 40
Reading Level: 4-8
Genre: Picture Book/Legend
Award: Caldecott Honor Book
"A tall tale and heroic myth, a celebration of the human spirit....The story is told with rhythm and wit, humor and exaggeration, and with a heart-catching immediacy that connects the human and the natural world."
- Booklist Review
Who would benefit from reading this book?: This great book would benefit all that took the time to read it. It follows the legend of John Henry really well and the readability is fairly easy. This is a classic African American tale which has been told for decades throughout the United States.
What problems/conflicts would this book potentially cause?: I don't think that there is anything within this book that would cause any problems. It was well written and follows the legend accurately. Some might venture to say that John Henry never really existed either way this story was created to inspire people. Whether John Henry existed or not isn't really the point of the book.
My reaction: Both of my parents grew up in West Virgina and I'm sure they had this story told to them many times growing up. I have great memories of my mom actually taking the time to tell me the story of John Henry. They took me to the New River Canyon where the tunnels were dug, and that is where the tale of John Henry began. In actuality, there were several John Henries and several tunnels, one of which is the Big Bend tunnel. I think the rhythm of book flows well and the illustrations done by Jerry Pinkney are simply gorgeous. I would recommend this book to all.
Wednesday, February 10, 2010
The Perfect Sword
By: Scott Goto
Publisher: Charlesbridge Publishing
Copyright: 2008
Pages: 48
Reading Level: 9-12
Genre: Picture Book/Fairy tale
Award: N/A
"The Perfect Sword is a moral tale about the virtues that make a person worthy of something perfect. "
- School Library Journal
Who would benefit from reading this book?: Anyone who would take the time to read this book would definitely feel inspired to live a better life. The story teaches one to live morally and to continue to strive to be the very best one could be. Its morals could be applied to any one's life and is the reason why this is a very beneficial book for children and even adults to read.
What problems/conflicts would this book potentially cause?: I don't think that this book would cause any problems or conflicts. Its storyline teaches one to continue to work towards one's personal best. It encourages one to deny oneself of all impurities.
My reaction: Out of all the books I've read thus far, this is by far my favorite book. The illustrations are simply magnificent and gorgeous. I would recommend this book to every person who is looking to be inspired. This is the type of book every parent and or teacher should have in there bookcase. I will be encouraging everyone to check this book out from the library.
By: Russell Punter
Publisher: Usborne Books
Copyright: 2003
Pages: 50
Reading Level: 1-6
Genre: Picture Book/Fairy tale with three different pirate tales
Award: N/A
The Three Pigs
By: David Wiesner
Publisher: Clarion Books
Copyright: 2001
Pages: 40
Reading Level: 4-8
Genre: Picture Book/Fairy tale
Award: The Caldecott Award 2002
"Wiesner has created a funny, wildly imaginative tale that encourages readers to leap beyond the familiar; to think critically about conventional stories and illustration, and perhaps, to flex their imaginations and create wonderfully subversive versions of their own stories."
- Booklist Review
Who would benefit from reading this book?: I think everyone who takes time to read this book or have it read to them will walk away gratified. This book starts off following the classic fairy tale "The Three Little Pigs" except Weisner adds his own little twist creating a fantasy land for all that reads this book. This book encourages readers to step out of the norm and use there own imagination to create a story of their own. That's why I think this book will benefit all who read it.
What problems/concerns would this book potentially cause? : I don't think this book would cause any concerns or problems.
My reaction: This book is brilliant. I loved how the illustrations follow some of the text, especially when it tells about the wolf getting ready to eat the pig, and then, in the illustration, the wolf has a confused look on his face as the pig is missing. I will recommend this book to every person who is looking for an adventure away from the norm. Imagination is encouraged in reading this book!
Lou Gehrig: The Luckiest Man
By: David Adler
Publisher: Voyager Books
Copyright: 1997
Pages: 32
Reading Level: 4-8
Genre: Picture Book/Biography
Award: N/A
"A touching tribute to the baseball superstar . . . Stunning illustrations."
- The Boston Globe
Who would benefit from reading this book?: Anyone who would come across this book should read it. This book inspires one to stand a little taller and live a little better. The most important lesson or theme that is taught within this book is the importance of being committed to whatever one chooses to do in life.
What problems/conflicts would this book potentially cause?: I don't think that this book will cause any problems or conflicts. It's an inspiring book written to encourage readers.
My reaction: This book is very inspiring and taught me many things I can do to live better. I truly think that was the primary purpose of this book. The illustrations ,even though done by Terry Widener, were suburb and unique. I particularly recommend this book to all baseball lovers.
Tuesday, February 9, 2010
The Monster Who Ate My Peas
By: Danny Schnitzlein
Publisher: Peachtree Publisher
Copyright: 2001
Pages: 32
Reading Level: 4-8
Genre: Picture Book/Adventure
Award: N/A
"Another yucky food story, this one told in rhyme. And it actually works."
- School Library Journal
Who would benefit for reading this book? : I think anyone who would read this great book would benefit from it. The readability of the book is simple for easy to intermediate readers and would make a great book to read aloud to children of all ages. One important theme that is taught is the important to try everything you do whether it be eating food or anything you do in life before you say you don't like it. Because it might not turn out as bad as it looks.
What problems/conflicts would this book potentially cause? : I don't there is any problems that this book would potentially cause.
My reaction: I enjoyed reading this book. This book had a certain rhythm to it's reading that makes this book enjoyable for readers of all ages. I especially enjoyed the illustrations of the book. I recommend this book to every parent who might be struggling with getting their own children to eat peas and any food like it.
Where The Wild Things Are
By: Maurice Sendak
Publisher: Harper Collins
Copyright: 1963
Pages: 42
Reading Level: 4-8
Genre: Picture Book/Adventure
Award: Caldecott Award Winner
"Each word has been carefully chosen and the simplicity of the language is quite deceptive."
-SLJ
Who would benefit from reading this book?: This is such a great book I recommend
What problems/concerns would this book potentially cause?: I don't think there are many concerns of problems this book would cause, if any at all. One potential problem is that in the beginning it shows disrespect for parents. But other than that, this is a positive book for children of all ages.
My reaction: I loved this book. I remember having this read to me as a child by my teachers in elementary school. This is truly Sendak's best book with some of the most unique pictures. These are shown within the 6 pages of nothing but pure illustrations. This is exactly the reason Sendak won the Caldecott Award for this remarkable book. I recommend this book to every parent and teacher.